The Hardest Conversation You Will Have in 2027

The 2027 AI Action Plan for Small Business · Post 7 of 8 · See the full series

Workforce Intelligence warns leaders that they will hear some version of this from their people:

“I just spent half my life honing a craft and building relationships, and I take tremendous pride in my work product. Now a technology can do it better, faster, and cheaper. What does this mean for my impact?”

Workforce Intelligence, Chapter 9

The authors treat this fear as rational, and I agree. It is a correct reading of what is happening, and it deserves a straight answer. The book’s most useful line on the subject is a distinction:

“The threat is not that AI will replace you. The threat is that AI will replace the portion of your work that you were mistaking for your value.”

Workforce Intelligence, Appendix B

That distinction explains why the usual reassurances fail.

What Not to Say

The book calls these standard responses hollow:

  • “Augmentation, not automation.”
  • “AI is here to help, not replace.”
  • “Your job is safe.”

Each contains some truth. The problem is that none of them answers what the person is really asking: will my work be augmented or automated? You probably don’t know yet. The book is candid that some jobs will be automated, others augmented, and new ones will appear, and nobody can say exactly which or when.

So don’t pretend to have the answer. Tell people what you do know, and say plainly what you don’t.

Two Assumptions Worth Addressing

The book identifies two beliefs behind most of this fear. Both deserve a direct answer.

The first is that there is an option where nothing changes. If AI could be adopted in a way that left everyone’s work exactly as it is while still giving clients more, every business would choose it. As Mike Sullivan asks in the book, “What is the alternative? Because if it exists, we would probably prefer it.” When a competitor can serve clients faster or more cheaply, the market moves whether you do or not. Standing still means becoming the slower option.

The second is that there is a fixed amount of work to go around. This belief says every task AI takes is a task lost to people. The book’s answer is that the amount of useful work depends on which problems are worth solving. Many problems go unsolved today because solving them costs too much. As AI lowers that cost, more of them become worth tackling, and many of those need people. The book points out that every major technology shift of the last century followed this pattern: tasks were automated, work expanded and jobs changed.

Your team knows that history. They will believe it from you if you say it plainly and don’t oversell it.

A Better Way to Frame It

The strongest reframe in the book comes from Bill Carew, President of OneDigital:

“Say you’ve been in this business for thirty years. You can only touch twenty-five to thirty clients a year. That is the ceiling of what you personally can reach. I do not need more people like you. I need more of you, specifically.”

Bill Carew, quoted in Workforce Intelligence, Chapter 9

This doesn’t deny the change, and it doesn’t promise the work will stay the same. It presents the change as a way to extend the person’s reach, and it treats the person as the thing worth scaling.

Meagan, a senior OneDigital practitioner who resisted the change before coming around to it, put it this way:

“The work you have done is not being taken away, but the category around the work is shifting. The practice you have built will look different after AI transformation, but the leader of that practice will continue to be you.”

Workforce Intelligence, Chapter 9

The practical point underneath both: when someone hands over the drafting, formatting and research, they have more time for judgment, relationships and reading the room. Those were always the parts clients valued most.

The Owner Is Usually the Most Exposed

In a small business, the person most threatened by AI is usually the owner.

You didn’t build the business by being adequate at many things. You built it by being very good at one or two, and that is often why clients choose you over a bigger competitor. Your identity and your business are closely tied together.

So when the exercise in Post 2 shows that some expert work is more reducible than it looks, the first person it applies to is you. If you haven’t mapped your own week yet, the 2027 AI Transformation Worksheet takes about an afternoon. Two things help here.

First, being good at that work was never a mistake. For most of your career, drafting, checking and assembling were the only way to get to the judgment that clients actually paid for.

Second, working out which parts of your week only you can do is a rare chance. Most owners never have time to ask. If the honest answer is a smaller share of your week than you expected, use it as a map of where to spend more of your time.

“Your decades of experience are not made less valuable by AI, but rather more valuable. Your expertise must change, though. You won’t keep up by doing the work the same way you’ve been doing it.”

Workforce Intelligence, Chapter 9

The Deal Has Two Sides

Reassurance only holds if it comes with commitments. The book describes a deal with obligations on both sides.

As the employer, you commit to:

  • Investing in people’s development before the market forces you to
  • Telling people honestly what is changing, even when it is uncomfortable
  • Measuring success partly by what AI gives back to your team in time and capability, not only by what it adds to profit
  • Working with people as their work changes, instead of simply managing them through it

Your team’s side is harder to say, but it needs saying. The book puts it directly:

“The professional who is standing flat-footed when the technology arrives at their role is not a victim of the technology. They are a victim of their own choice not to move when moving was still optional.”

Workforce Intelligence, Chapter 11

Most owners say they intend to keep their side. Goldman Sachs found that 87% of small business owners say AI augments rather than displaces their employees. In a small business, your team will find out quickly whether your actions match those words.

A Structure for the Conversation

If you are sitting down with someone next week, here is a structure. Use your own words.

StepWhat to say or do
1. Be honest about the change“I want to talk about AI and your work. I’m not going to tell you nothing changes, because some of it will.”
2. Say what you know and what you don’t“Here’s what I think changes first. Here’s what I don’t know yet.”
3. Answer the real questionBe specific about which tasks are likely to change, even if your answer is incomplete
4. Name what only they can do“Clients stay with us because of how you handle the difficult conversations.”
5. Make a specific offer“I’ll protect two hours a week for you to work on this, starting next week, and I’ll do it with you.”
6. Ask what worries themThen stop talking and listen

The last step takes the most nerve, and it is what makes the rest believable.

Your Next Steps

Say something to your team this week, even if it isn’t polished. For example: “I’ve been putting off talking about AI because I didn’t have a clean answer. I still don’t, but I’d rather we work it out together, and I want to hear what worries you.”

Then choose one person whose transition you will personally support, and book an hour with them this month.

The Focus HR consulting team helps Arizona owners plan these conversations, including how to handle role changes fairly and in line with employment law.

Talk to the Focus HR team

About the author: Clint Parry, MBA, SHRM-SCP is a Senior Business Consultant at Focus HR, where he helps Arizona small businesses with HR strategy, compliance and workforce planning. Focus HR is powered by OneDigital. This post is part of The 2027 AI Action Plan for Small Business series.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to Top